Published in 2008, this seems to be one of the seminal scientific studies of the paleo diet in modern Europeans.
Their version of the paleo diet:
- Allowed ad lib: All fresh or frozen fruits, berries and vegetables except legumes, canned tomatoes w/o additives, fresh or frozen unsalted fish and seafood, fresh or frozen unsalted lean meats and minced meat, unsalted nuts (except peanuts – a legume), fresh squeezed lemon or lime juice (as dressing), flaxseed or rapeseed oil (as dressing), coffee and tea (w/o sugar, milk, honey, or cream), all salt-free spices.
- Allowed but with major restrictions: dried fruit, salted seafood, fat meat, potatoes (two medium-sized per day), honey, cured meats
- Prohibited: all milk and dairy products, all grain products (including corn and rice), all legumes, canned food except tomatoes, candy, ice cream, soft drinks, juices, syrups, alcohol, sugar, and salt
What Did They Find After Three Weeks?
- Average weight dropped from 65.2 kg (144 lb) to 62.9 (139 lb)
- Average body mass index fell from 22.2 to 21.4
- Average waist circumference decreased from 74.3 cm (29.25″) to 72.6 cm (28.58″)
- Average systolic blood pressure fell from 110 to 104 mmHg
- plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 decreased from 5.0 kIE/l to 2.8 kIE/l
- All of these changes were statistically significant
The researchers looked at a number of other blood tests and didn’t find any significant differences.
Five men and nine women completed the study. Of the 20 who originally signed up, one could not fulfill the diet, three became ill (no details), two failed to show up.
That’s a remarkable weight loss over just three weeks for slender people eating ad lib.
The study authors concluded that these paleo diet-induced changes could reduce risk for cardiovascular disease. They called for a larger study with a control group. (If it’s been done, I haven’t found it yet.)
PS: You’d think they would have said more about the three participants who got sick, rather than leave us wondering if the diet made them ill.
Reference: Österdahl, M; Kocturk, T; Koochek, A;Wändell, PE. Effects of a short-term intervention with a paleolithic diet in healthy volunteers. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 62 (2008): 682-685.
So your comment was that the diet produced “remarkable weight loss” … Really?
My comment would be that the diet was a massive failure, if 60 percent of the participants dropped out in just three weeks.
Hey, Jim. You caught one of my rare mistakes! Thank God I hadn’t emptied my trashcan yet so I could go back to the source.
In the original post I wrote “Five men and three women completed the study.” Actually, five men and 9 women completed it; the drop-out rate was 33%. It’s probably not fair to include the two no-shows (after they signed up) in the drop-out rate, but I did.
This was not a weight-loss study. It was “let’s do this and see what happens” study. These med students were pretty light at the outset; One might interpret the weight loss as an adverse effect of the diet.
I went back and corrected my mistake in the original post.
According to the abstract, energy intake was reduced by 36%.
I can’t help but think that this is a result of (unintentional) carbohydrate restriction.
That’s the thing about studying Paleo diets. While not necessarily low-carb in theory, they tend to be low-carb in practice. Hard to tell if it’s the quantity or the quality of carbs that produce the results, or even the inclusion/exclusion of some other foods.
You should know that the odds are agiasnt you. Most people who lose weight gain it all back. But this doesn’t mean that you are destined to become such a statistic. There are people who do experience long-term weight-loss success. To be one of them, you need to realize that it is possible to keep the weight off—and even to lose more. But since it may be difficult at times, you need to be realistic and plan how you’ll overcome the struggles.I think that it’s important to be told the real deal. If you’re aware of what it takes to lose and keep weight off and then you commit to doing it, you will succeed. It’s as simple as that.The body’s physiological response to losing weight may mean that you feel hungrier than normal, or think of food more often. Or you may feel lazier and inclined to reduce all your spontaneous activity (jumping up to do run errands, putting extra vigor into housework, playing with your kids or pets), thereby preserving energy. It appears that the body’s tendency to revert back to previous body weight can be triggered even from losing just five to 10 percent of your starting weight. So if you weighed 200 and lost 10 to 20 pounds or you weighed 150 pounds and lost 8 to 15 pounds, you may have to work hard in order to maintain that loss.Most people look for the best diets to lose weight. But what scientists have realized is that losing weight is the easy part. Most diets, healthy or not, do work. You can drop pounds fairly quickly, especially the more overweight you are . But no matter how you lose the weight, the real challenge is to keep it off long-term.If you’ve been overweight or obese for two years, 10 years, or 20 years, a short-term diet or fitness plan won’t solve your problem. Obesity is a chronic disorder which requires a long-term approach. What you can’t do is follow a program such as the Lose 10 Pounds in 5 Weeks plan, and then revert back to those behaviors that made you overweight or obese in the first place. Once you’ve lost weight and you are trying to maintain the loss, or lose even more, you will find that, at times, it will be difficult. But, you will also experience periods where you enjoy eating more healthfully and your exercise sessions feel easy.Beware of being disillusioned. Many books, magazines and weight-loss products trying to motivate you into buying their plans purposefully make things sound easier than they are. Yes, you can lose weight and keep it off. You can get fit and stay fit. But is it as easy as spending a few minutes per week using an exercise gizmo? Or will one simple diet food or supplement do the trick? No.You are going to have to stay disciplined—and keep finding ways to stay motivated to do so. You’ll be faced with temptations and you’ll have to find ways to resist or avoid them. In today’s busy world, environmental factors such as fast-food chains everywhere and too many sedentary activities like TV-watching, driving and using computers, lead you to eat more and exercise less.But your environment, and more importantly, how you respond to it is something you can control. Some people who strive to lose weight may simply have a physiology that means it will always feel like a struggle to eat well and exercise. But many people who have been able to stick to healthier living for a long time swear that it gets easier the longer you do it.
You sound like a seasoned bariatric pro. There’s a boatload of wisdom in what you wrote.
Pingback: Proven Health News » Blog Archive » Short-Term Effects of a Paleolithic Diet in Healthy Medical Students …